Charles Schooley: City Paymaster and Prominent Baptist

Update (Originally posted August 2014):

Charles Abraham Schooley - FBC LIfe Deacon and COV Chief Paymaster

Charles Abraham Schooley. n.d. First Baptist Church (Vancouver) Archives.

Charles Abraham Schooley (1850-1931) was born in Port Colborne, Ontario. He studied law for a couple of years but ultimately withdrew from that course of study due to illness. He then was one of the first men to enter into the moss trade (of all things) while in Florida for a few years. He returned to Ontario where he began working with the Hobbs Hardware Co. of London until he came to Vancouver in 1889 with his recently-wed wife, Kate Eastman Schooley (nee Samons, of Hamilton). When he got to Vancouver, he worked at first as an agent with Imperial Oil Co. and later as a wholesale produce dealer. Finally, in 1905, he became a City employee, working initially with the Treasury department and, two years later, being promoted to the post of Chief Paymaster.*

Schooley became a member of First Baptist Church shortly after establishing his residence here. He served as a Deacon and as Church Clerk for many years. In January 1925, he was made an Honorary Deacon in recognition of his many years of exemplary service.**

When the Schooleys first came to the city, they lived on Howe Street between Smithe and Nelson. By 1908, they’d moved to 2020 Beach Avenue – a home on the south side of Beach near Chilco Street. By 1911, however, the City wanted to create a string of parkland east of Stanley Park and so, as part of that plan, Schooley’s beachfront property was purchased by the City’s Land Purchasing Agent for $13,513.60.

S-5-15 - English Bay [and Beach Avenue West of Chilco Street looking east]  ca1896

CVA S-5-15 – English Bay [and Beach Avenue West of Chilco Street looking east]. ca1896. The Schooley residence at 2020 Beach Ave. would have been along here.

The Schooleys moved to their final residence at 2057 Pendrell Street in 1914.

VW 29 Sept 1922-1

Schooley’s job as City Paymaster wasn’t without drama. On September 29th, 1922 at 10.15am, Schooley and his aide, Bob Armstrong, “were slugged by three auto[mobile] bandits and relieved of a civic payroll of $75,000, while a crowd of terrified Chinese, who were standing by, scattered from a fusillade of three shots fired by the robbers.” (Vancouver Daily World, September 22, 1922). (We will leave to one side the question of whether three shots may accurately be called a fusillade.)

Neither Schooley nor Armstrong seem to have suffered serious injury. City Hall, at that time, was in the Old Market Hall. The two City employees were returning to City Hall from the bank, where they had picked up the payroll.

I originally thought that the culprits were never brought to book for this crime. However, evidence from commenter Mr. Wolfe below shows that at least one of the thieves ultimately was arrested: Ted Hollywood.  Hollywood was reportedly sentenced to serve 14 years ‘hard labor’ in New Westminster’s penitentiary for the 1922 payroll theft and also for aiding in a robbery of the Capital Theatre in Vancouver in February, 1923. (May 4, 1925 – Nanaimo Daily News). For more details on Hollywood’s career of crime, please see Mr. Wolfe’s comment below.

Kate Schooley pre-deceased her husband in 1927. Schooley died in 1931 at the age of 84.

Charles and Kate Schooley seem to have been childless. I had initially wondered whether Jennie Schooley, a teacher at Strathcona School from  1928-1959, might have been their daughter, but I later learned that she was the daughter of another local Schooley: William Francis Schooley.


*These early details of Schooley’s life were found in British Columbia From Earliest Times to the Present: Biographical. Volume IV. 1914. S. J. Clarke Publishing Co., p. 819.

**Mrs. Schooley was a devout member of a different church: St. John’s Presbyterian (just a few blocks from First Baptist).

This entry was posted in biography, city, First Baptist Church, Vancouver and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Charles Schooley: City Paymaster and Prominent Baptist

  1. Mark Wolfe says:

    The payroll robbery referred to above wasn’t solved for a couple of years, but there was at least one arrest and conviction. The Seattle Daily Times reported on April 30, 1925, that James Theodore Hollywood, aka Ted Hollywood, aka C.C. Thompson, aka J.T. Hull was found guilty of the crime. His sentencing was reported in the same paper on May 4, 1925. He had previously been involved in a theft in Seattle in 1919 and a payroll robbery in Springfield, MO in 1922. In 1935 he was deported to the U.S., and in 1937, after conviction for participating in the robbery of a safe at a bakery in Seattle, he was determined to be an habitual offender and received a life sentence in the Washington State Penitentiary. He was paroled in 1951 (not much of a life sentence), and returned to his life of crime. In 1963 he was convicted of a bank robbery in Portland, Oregon and probably spent a few years in the Oregon state Prison. He died in 1969 and is buried in Missouri, his home state. My father was one of the Oregon State Police officers who arrested Hollywood in 1963.

    • mdm says:

      Thanks much for these details as to the arrest of one of thieves apparently responsible for the assault and theft of Paymaster Schooley. I appreciate it!

  2. bwcarey says:

    interesting times

  3. Great of you to chime in with information like that Mark Wolfe.

    Theatres were popular targets for robberies in the days before bank cards and credit cards. After a busy weekend, from all the box office cash and concession money, those theatres were full of cash, and often little security. I wrote a little piece in the Courier about a few old theatre robberies of the past…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s